Review: HD Downloads via Akimbo
Here at HDBeat we love to find new HD content and for
some reason it seems more exciting when we can download it, this is partly because we can stream the HD content to our
Xbox360. A few weeks ago there was a press
release about Akimbo and HDNet working together to bring HD content to people via the Internet so I decided to
check it out.Things started out on the right foot; their website was nice looking and easy to navigate. I was a little hazy
on the details at first but with a little digging I figured out how it works. You can either use a Windows Media Center
Edition plugin or a stand alone STB. I didn't try the the Stand alone STB because it doesn't support HD, plus I already
own a MCE. You can download the plugin from their website or via the "Online Spotlight" section of MCE. I used
the online spotlight and signed up for a 31 day free trial, after which the subscription fee goes to $9.99 per month. A
31 day trial is great, I always feel so pressured when the trial is only for 30 days. Aside from filling out your name
and address it is easy to setup using the MCE remote. You do have to give a credit card, but more about that later.
After everything is installed and configured you can access the plugin from the "More Programs" section, it's
too bad Microsoft doesn't let 3rd parties add content to the main menu. 
The menu for the
software is pretty easy to navigate, but like most MCE plugins they don't run as smoothly as MCE itself. The other
problem is that the back button doesn't work the way you expect it to in MCE, but luckily they warn you before leaving
the plugin. It would be nice if it worked more like MCE does, but it gets the job done. Once again this may be a
limitation of the MCE API.
Although I have never heard of most of the programming,
the overall selection is overwhelming. There are some shows from the History channel, my personal favorite "Modern
Marvels" among others, (I have emailed the History channel begging them to produce the show in HD, but as you might
imagine I haven't received a response.) there were even some Video Podcasts and other original Internet content. I
didn't see a way to only search for HD content, but I was able to easily find the HDNet channel, which has been
recently added. I was a bit disappointed in the HD selection, but I expect it's because they just started to carry
HDNet content. From HDNet they had one episode of True Music(e22), and a bunch
of episodes of Bikini Destination and Young
Beautiful and trying to make it in Hollywood. Some of the content was free (with subscription), but most of the
shows from cable, including the HDNet shows are between $0.49 and $9.99. Each month they will charge the $9.99 monthly
fee to your credit card as well as the Pay Per View content with a detailed bill. 
Once
you find a show you want you set it to download and it the show is added to a queue, you can even download shows
remotely so they will be ready when you get home. It appears to only download one show at a time, but automatically
goes through the queue one by one, like you would expect. The first thing I downloaded was True Music (The married guys understand why I didn't download the other shows.) which costs $4.99 and
took just under 2 hours to download. Considering the file was 1.4GB I felt like this was a long time. When I perform a
bandwidth test from my ISPs test site I usually see about 6Mbs so a 1.4GB file should take about 32 minutes. I am not
sure where the problem is but waiting 3 times the length of the show seems like a big too long, but it is hard to blame
Akimbo. The video quality was very good with no noticeable compression. I will admit that I didn't watch it very long,
so I is possible that if I watched it longer I might of noticed some problems. The clip was 1280x720 and encoded with
WMV 6.7Mbs video and 192Kbps WMA9.1 audio and regretfully no 5.1, at least that my AV decoder could decode via SPDIF.
The quality was without a doubt high enough to enjoy and with the right selection of content I could see myself
canceling Satellite. Using the service with the Xbox360 worked perfectly, just like most MCE features they run
perfectly on the Xbox360 and this is no exception.
Overall I was impressed, but I wouldn't stay satisfied
very long with the limited selection. Judging by the amount of content they have now, I would be surprised if they
didn't add many more HD shows in the coming months. The costs seems a little high if you want to cancel your cable,
between the monthly fee and the per episode fee for many of the shows. They do have subscriptions that could help, but
in some regards it isn't like DVD, because some of the content expires.
















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Chris @ Apr 14th 2006 1:01PM
I see services like this as the future of TV. Consumers will no longer be locked down to a choice of Satellite or their local cable company. Hopefully consumers will be able to choose from a variety of telvesion service providers such as Akimbo, iTunes, Movielink, etc, each which will offer their own pricing scheme. I just jope that they can all get access to the common cable channels and networks and that exclusive deals are not reached to lock out competitors.
Griffon @ Apr 14th 2006 1:58PM
Akimbo is a great idea. Unfortunately they are hobbled beyond usability by the IP owners (or so I believe).
1. Pay to pay more. Subscription fee's for what? Almost everything worth watching has a another fee on top of it. Greedy shot sighted Ip owner doing? Probable, but it makes their service a very murky value proposition
2. Expiration. that show you just spent five bucks on? Take a look, it has an expiration window and is going to go away regardless of if you watch it. Though I'm sure they would be happy to let you pay for it it again...and again. This totally flys in the face of what DVR's are for. Lets see I can spend money on all this stuff then be out of town for to weeks and have not be there when I'm ready for it.. course I could pay to get it again...and again... Come on.
3. DRM hell. You can watch it on your MCE box or stream it to a registered extender(until some IP owner decides they should get an extra cut for streaming I would assume). But you can't move it to portable or do anything else with it like stream it via orb. You can't even redirect the content via their website or access it that way if you happen to be else where. So you are very limited for your monthly fee plus per object fee.
This is a great lesson on how IP owners can suck the value out of new service and keep them from really going anywhere (like to wide acceptance or to be being able to compete with cable/sat).
I have something like 40-50 season passes, if the content was available to match that (and it's not even close for mainstream stuff), I shutter to think what using Akimbo as a cable replacement would cost monthly.