HDTV Buying Guide: Xbox 360 Edition

The eve of HD gaming is upon us. I'm sure that you have your Xbox 360 pre-ordered with the quickest route to the store that morning all mapped out. You probably have picked up some games and the already know the controller from the hours you have spent at Wal-Mart. You're ready for the 360 but where is your HDTV for your next gen console?
Many gamers, not unlike yourself, are ready for the Xbox 360 but do not have a HDTV nor do they knew what to look for to maximize their investment. There are so many options out there that choosing the right set for your lifestyle can be overwhelming. So HD Beat presents the HDTV Buying Guide: Xbox 360 edition.
Things to consider
The 360 itself needs to be considered when looking for a HDTV. Your gaming habits as well can steer you towards a certain type of TV. Mostly what it boils down to is your cash. But that’s OK; we'll show you what types of TVs you can get while staying in your budget that will maximize that brand new Xbox.Before we start though lets clear some things up. First, the 360 does not have HDMI or DVI. The $400 package ships with component cables (red, green, blue, red, & white) and so far there is no announcement from Microsoft that it will ever support HDMI. Most HDTVs now have the digital connections but you won't be using them with the new Xbox.
Second, you don't need an HDTV to use the 360. In fact, your TV might be good enough for you; those gamers that have a 27-inch or smaller set will find that HDTV is not that much better in those sizes. If you're low on cash, try your TV first with the component cables and you might be surprised. The Xbox has the ability to drop the resolution down all the way to 480i, which any TV can handle. The graphics are still going to be amazingly clean and smooth.
Lastly, don't worry about the actual resolution of the TV; instead, consider what type of digital signals it can display. The Xbox only supports a few resolutions but try to find a TV that can do 720p. Yes, 1080i is a higher resolution but it can only do 30 frames a second, while 720p displays 60 frames a second. Therefore, even though it has fewer lines of resolution, 720p produces a smoother picture so it's a better way to display fast moving objects.
Plasmas and LCD/DLPs are mostly 720p displays while rear-projection CRTs do 1080i natively. Most 1080i sets will drop down and produce 720p but some will not: certain Panasonic tube HDTVs, for example. Make sure you ask the salesman to show you what the TV can do and if they can't, go somewhere else.
Budget of a high school student or college freshman:
$0 - $499
Ok, you just dropped $400 on the console and an extra $60 for a game so your cash is a little strapped but you still need
that HDTV. Well, if you decided that your hand-me-down 24-incher is
not good enough, we have a few ideas that might fit the bill. Look for a 27-inch tube that is high-definition capable. Sometimes you can find 26-inch widescreens under $500 as well, which would be the TV of choice for HD gaming because of the widescreen. If you want to maximize your buying power, look for 30-inch “out of the box” or "floor-model" specials at brick and mortar stores that would give you more screen for your money even if they are used. Often times, these sets still come with warranties.
Sure, these TVs are all tubes and might not look "cool", but they don't suffer from short lives or burn-in. Nor do they drop pixels or have lamps that need to be replaced. They will give you a great TV for the money.
Budget of a live-at-home 20-something or productive young adult:
$500-$999
This
range can be fun but confusing. For example, $899 will get a consumer
ether a high-end 30-inch tube or an entry level 26-inch LCD. If it was
me, I would choose the tube every time (better blacks and response
time) and Christmas is going to favor this budget a lot. But remember
to watch-out for tube TVs that don't support 720p, like certain Panasonic models.Christmas will help out gamers this year and there have been reports of major electronic stores having 26-inch LCDs for $500 the day after thanksgiving. Plus, gamers will be able to find entry-level 46 to 51-inch rear projections for under a grand. Big screens are great for large-scale gaming but if you've never owned one and plan on watching basic cable on it, you may want to ask the salesman to pop it on a normal station. Perhaps after buying the 360 and the TV to go with it, you don't have the cash to spend high-def cable and rear-projections have never been known for high quality pictures.
Budget of older gamers or those that have parents with deep pockets:
$1000-$1999
This is where the real choices are at. Gamers are a weird crowd and want the $1700 could get you one of these.
- A high-end tube - 34-inch Sony XBR
- a mid-range LCD - 32-inch Samsung
- a high-end rear-projection - 57-inch Hitachi
- a 42-inch LCD/DLP - 42-inch Samsung
- even a ED plasma - 42-inch Panasonic
We're looking for a HDTV for high-def gaming though and the plasma is not HD so lets throw that one out. The LCD is not the best and doesn' have a great response time. The tube will give you the best black levels and the best colors but it's small. This leaves us with the rear-projection sets.
A nice CRT rear-projection will give a gamer a great big experience. There is some slight possibility for burn-in on any CRT type display, but that is so rare; as long as you are aware of it, there should be no problem. The LCD/DLP however will give a person a quicker and smoother picture courtesy of 720p.
Credit, credit, credit:
$2,000 plus
Everything
we have talked about before applies but just at a larger scale. The
only thing that is different is that a gamer could get a high-def
plasma. Gamers, and people in general, have frowned at plasma because
of burn-in issues. These problems have been reduced and should not
cause the average gamer any problems, but if you are one to pull
all-nighters, then perhaps you should look elsewhere. For some gamers, money is not a problem and those new 1080p sets may look very tempting. But you need to be careful. Most of them do not accept a 1080p signal but rather take the 1080i and convert up to it. (Sony SXRDs and Samsung 78 series DLPs for example) This is not a problem for the 720p/1080i Xbox 360 but the PS3 does support 1080p gaming. If you can wait to get a 1080p TV until there is more widespread support for 1080p inputs, it would be a wiser investment.
Whatever TV you decide to pair with that brand new 360 will be great. Just make sure that it supports 720p and has component inputs. The fine details like size and types are up to you but we hope that this guide helped to steer you in the right path. Share your thoughts in our comments and tell us what HDTV set you're pairing up with a new Xbox 360!
















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Chrise @ Nov 12th 2005 2:39PM
You should mention the FULL HD-support which is this details!
Make sure that the HDTV-Ready you buy can atleast
1280x720@50Hz progressivt (720p 50Hz)
1280x720@60Hz progressivt (720p 60Hz) solution, DVI/HDMI and with HDCP.
Then if you want to buy a HDTV which will support Playstation 3, which is called for Full-HD must support this details down here
1280x720@50Hz progressivt (720p 50Hz)
1280x720@60Hz progressivt (720p 60Hz)
1920x1080@50Hz interlaced (1080i 50Hz)
1920x1080@60Hz interlaced (1080i 60Hz)
Martin @ Nov 12th 2005 2:49PM
You're wrong when you say "so far there is no announcement from Microsoft that it will ever support HDMI." Check here:
http://interviews.teamxbox.com/xbox/1190/Xbox-360-Interview-Todd-Holmdahl/p1/
Microsoft "...will provide an HDMI for our customers when it makes sense." Not massively different from what you said, but better than nothing.
Richard Lawler @ Nov 12th 2005 2:51PM
It's been suggested, most notably by Henning over at HDBlog.net that the out on the 360 is not capable of outputing to a DVI or HDMI cable. Whether this is true or not I don't know, but it's been suggested so until otherwise I'd plan around the connectors offered.
daniel oegerle @ Nov 12th 2005 3:38PM
I'm in the $2,000 and up range, and I am planning on buying a 42"-50" PDP. I have looked at some, the Pioneer, Panasonic, Philips, LG, but there are so many choices I don't know which to get. What is confusing is that these sets say that they are HDTV, but the resolutions say that they are all 1024 x 768. What's that mean, only for DVI connectivity to my computer?
Andrew Lohmann @ Nov 12th 2005 3:43PM
Timely post; thank you. I think you saved me from purchasing the wrong television.
freestufftimes.com @ Nov 12th 2005 4:02PM
I suggest you go here, buy this tv, and enter code TCADVJAB for 100 bucks off. YOu wont find a better deal on a great 32" lcd with a great response time http://www.target.com/gp/detail.html//602-0560383-0280665?asin=B000B9UX6Q
JustMe @ Nov 12th 2005 6:21PM
I think Im fine.. I have an 34-inch Sony XBR, but its 4:3 not 16:9.. Here where I live only the 36(or bigger)-inch XBR is wide screen and those dont fit in my bedroom. :P 34inch 4:3 its not bad, because the HDTV modes are the size of 31-inch... Think that I have 2 TVs in one. An HDTV of 31 and an TV 34 with progressive. Not bad. The colors and the bright of the Sony XBR are amazing! Im happy with my choice. Only waiting for the Xbox360.
Al @ Nov 12th 2005 6:59PM
ZildjianKX: CRTs are in fact the only displays that actually support native interlaced and progressive scan--they just alter the scanning pattern of the CRT beam as nec. Digital displays in general are ONLY progressive scan, and must de-interlace all interlaced video, and that is where you get artifacts.
Scott @ Nov 12th 2005 9:06PM
I purchased A Sharp Aquos 37" LC-37GB5U HDTV for $1,799 online a month back. It is fantastic. No burn in and no motion blur that I can see. LCD prices are coming down and assuming the response time ok are better than Plasmas for gaming.
Xbox 360 News @ Nov 12th 2005 9:24PM
Excellent information, thanks!
Ty @ Nov 12th 2005 10:30PM
Thanks for the great article... there's a lot of confusion out there, direction is always appreciated.
ZildjianKX @ Nov 13th 2005 1:29AM
Can a CRT HDTV actualy display progressive and interlaced sources? I ask because a lot of Sony CRT TVs say they are 1080i native, but support 720p and 480p... so do they upconvert them to 1080i to an interlaced signal, or do they actually support true 720p and 480p?
jluka @ Nov 13th 2005 3:25AM
I cant agree with your solution for xbox360, in my opinion THE definitive display is a FRONT projector with a 1280X720 matrix.
Suggested products: Panasonic AE900 or Sanyo Z4: the best 720p LCD and better than comparable DLP.
You can play on a 100" display!!!
My Panasonic is already waiting :-)
http://www.projectorcentral.com/panasonic_ae900.htm
http://www.projectorcentral.com/ae900_pe7700.htm
Jluka
Pierre @ Nov 13th 2005 4:30AM
For anyone that can help me, I was actually looking at the Sony Qualia 006 and was wondering if it would be a good investment and go well with the Xbox 360. Anyone who could lend thier opinion would be much appreciated.
robert semp @ Nov 13th 2005 7:46AM
By the way in the "Budget of a high school student or college freshman" catagory you shold mention that most vga monitors can display 720p and you can buy the vga cable for only $40 (20)
mike @ Nov 13th 2005 9:04AM
What about getting a screen with a 1366*768 resolution?
Is that not good? Most 40'' upwards LCD are in this resolution in Europe.
thanks!
Malcolm @ Nov 13th 2005 9:30AM
I was planning on buying the Sony 60 SXRD. One of the major reasons was because I was under the impression that it can handle 1080P signals and if I was going to spend a couple of thousand dollars anyway I might as well get the top of the line something that was going to be able to provide the best picture for years to come. Can someone explain to me what was meant by Most of them do not accept a 1080p signal but rather take the 1080i and convert up to it.
dwayne @ Nov 13th 2005 10:05AM
I have a sony 55in hd with 1366*768 res, I currently watch satellite in hd and i cant tell the difference from 1080p, to enhance my hd exbox360 experience I also have infinity modulus 2 speakers combined with a pioneer reciever which sounds amazing. PS. is it possible to get any equiptment to work with my 23in hd apple monitor, so far my upconvert hd dvd does not support it even though it has a seperate power supply.
freestufftimes.com @ Nov 13th 2005 10:27AM
While I agree that a projector is a great way to get a big screen, some people simply don't have the right room, or they have too much light, etc..
Matt Burns @ Nov 13th 2005 10:45AM
dwayne, while I am sure that your TV is great it is not even 1080p capiable. In fact, it cannot do do 1080i ether. If you are putting your DirecTV reciever on the 1080i setting and trying to see the difference from 720p, you will not see anything different. The TV is taking the higher resolution and "scaling" it down to the native resolution of the set which is 720p.
Also, you mentioned if it is possiable to hook up HD equipement to a Apple monitor. Sure, your direcTV box is probally HDMI so you will need to get a HDMI to DVI cable/adaptor to make it work. Same thing for your upconvision DVD player.
Thanks for the question!
Matt Burns @ Nov 13th 2005 10:51AM
Malcolm. It sure is disapointing to hear that something you have been coveting for so long does not live up to the hype. The Sony SXRD is a amazing TV but it does not handle a 1080p signal. It can take a 1080i signal and interally scale it up to 1080p which still produces a better picture but is not true 1080p from the source.
If you are a person that is planning on buying this TV as an investment and want a future-proof set, this is not the right one for you.
You may want to check out a few reviews of the SXRD.
http://www.hdbeat.com/2005/11/09/home-theater-reviewed-sony-60-sxrd/
http://www.hdbeat.com/2005/10/26/hd-beat-reader-review-sony-sxrd/
http://www.hdbeat.com/2005/10/15/hd-beat-review-sony-kds-r50xbr1/
Thanks for the question!
Matt Burns @ Nov 13th 2005 11:02AM
Pierre. The Sony Qualia products are the best money can buy...most of the time. The Qualia 006 is amazing but it is hard for me to say a "good investment." The set will quickly be outdated by this time next year and purhaps even in 6 months. It can accept a 1080p signal that its little brothers cannot, but is that the only reason you are ready to drop an extra 8 grand on the set?
But if you want the best that Sony makes at the biggest possiable size, buy the 006; if you can find it. Sony discontinued the Qualia brand a few months ago. Engadget covered it but the link to the story is running into server problems so this link may not work.
http://www.engadget.com/entry/1234000740059899/
They are still around 'cause Sony sure does not want to drop the profit margin on the big guy. Beautiful TV though.
Thanks for the question!
Matt Burns @ Nov 13th 2005 11:08AM
JustMe. I am curious to learn where you live. To the best of my knowledge, Sony did not make a 34-inch 4:3 TV, and in fact, the 36-inch is the 4:3 model here in the US.
Matt Burns @ Nov 13th 2005 11:15AM
daniel oegerle. It seems that you are looking for a display that can double as a computer monitor, right? Ok, so you will need to look for the rare higher resolution plasmas, but are you sure you want a plasma. There are some high resolution plasmas out there in your price range but you need to look hard at how you plan on using the display.
Yes, burn-in is rare, but only if the TV is used as a TV. The plasma has a HIGH potential of suffering from burn-in though if it is used as a computer monitor due to the Start Bar/Dock. If the set is only going to be used as a computer monitor for games and picture view, stuff like that, buy a plasma. But if you plan on making this your primary display for your computer, buy a LCD. Sure the LCDs are not the best color or black level, but there is no burn-in.
Here is a few sets to get you started
Plasma:
http://www.circuitcity.com/ssm/Hitachi-42-Plasma-HDTV-42HDF52-/sem/rpsm/oid/126025/catOid/-12867/rpem/ccd/productDetail.do
http://www.circuitcity.com/ssm/Hitachi-42-Plasma-HDTV-42HDS52-/sem/rpsm/oid/126026/catOid/-12867/rpem/ccd/productDetail.do
LCD
http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage.jsp?skuId=6998378&type=product&id=1110265591243
Thanks for the question!
pete @ Nov 13th 2005 11:17AM
Westinghouse LVM-37W1.
37" LCD- 1920x1080 for $1600, 'nuff said.
Matt Burns @ Nov 13th 2005 11:20AM
mike. Take a look at the comment two above this one to start.
***Waiting***
Ok, plasmas burn-in is rare if you use it as a TV. There are a few manufactors that include burn-out devices like Samsung and Hitachi. I am sure there is more.
They produce a white screen that takes the image and flushes it out. It takes a few minutes but it will wipe the plasma from any burn-in. If your TV does not have one of these devices built in then most large brick and mortar stores have techs that can do it for your but for a cost.
Thanks for the question!
Shawn @ Nov 13th 2005 1:00PM
Mike #16 The 1366x768 is an HD capable signal (in 720p and 1080i) The number represents the lines virtical and horizontal (or pixals VxH) As you can see by the first post.... When buying an HDTV make sure they have those numbers or higher.
Ty @ Nov 13th 2005 5:00PM
I don't know if there are any TV's currently avalible that can accept a 1080p signal... i know none of them can threw the HDMI slot, they havne't created copy protection for 1080p yet
if you have your heart set on getting full use out of your PS3 and future HD-Disc formats you should probably wait a few more months.
cacophony @ Nov 13th 2005 5:46PM
The HP RPTVs will accept a 1080p input over their HDMI inputs, and have received very favorable reviews on AVSForums and industry rags. They make a 65" and 58" version.
Disclaimer: I'm waiting for my HP 65" display to be delivered...chose it over the Sony SXRD specifically because it's better suited for gaming/HTPC use given the 1080p inputs.
mike @ Nov 13th 2005 8:30PM
Question.
what about burn ins on plasma screens???? Is there a workaround for not getting ghost images on your plasma?
Andrew @ Nov 13th 2005 10:39PM
i don't really know much about tvs but will this one be good for my 360?
http://www.bestbuy.ca/catalog/proddetail.asp?logon=&langid=EN&sku_id=0926HDS0010067662&catid=23244
Matt Burns @ Nov 13th 2005 10:49PM
Andrew, that TV would be great for gaming.
Mike @ Nov 14th 2005 12:07AM
I have a 62 inch mitsubishi DLP projection tv. Will anything bad happened if I play my xbox 360 on it. I had a ps2 that I connected with component cables connected and after about a month the tv started freezing at times so I had to discontinue usage of my ps2 on the tv. Thanks!
Tucker @ Nov 14th 2005 12:33PM
Dwayne, you can't tell the difference between 1080p for the following reasons:
1) Unless you're hooking up to a PC, you're not going to find ANY 1080p content ANYWHERE.
2) Your TV is 1366 x 768 and cannot play a 1080p signal natively (it would need to be 1920x1080 to display 1080p)
3) X360 can't do 1080p anyway
But an X360 will probably look HOT on that 55-inch screen.
As for your CinemaDisplay... The reason your upconverting DVD player won't work with it is most likely HDCP - good old copy protection. To display a HDCP-protected signal the monitor has to support it (a DVI connection with HDCP). I have no idea whether the Apple monitors support HDCP (probably not, since they're marketed as computer monitors and not TVs), but if it does, you might simply need a new cable.
Your best bet for playing stellar-looking DVDs on that monitor is to do it through software with your Mac (I'm assuming you have a Mac if you have an Apple display) or PC. Maybe HDBeat can throw together a little piece on FFDSHOW or other software that will upconvert a signal on a computer. Try wading through some of the technical stuff at www.avsforums.com and you'll find more than you would ever need to know. Hope this helps!
Tucker @ Nov 14th 2005 12:36PM
Ty - my Sceptre 37" set does 1080p just fine. There are a few 1080p sets on the market now, just not from the gigantic name-brand companies (who generally use the same LCD panels and charge 50% more than the "small" guys).
Home Theater Dude @ Nov 14th 2005 2:20PM
#14 is right on, though I may suggest different projectors.
There is nothing like gaming at 8 feet plus. It's not that hard to make different rooms work. You can control light with some different options as well.
HeyTeon @ Nov 17th 2005 5:37PM
I think LCD's do gamers the best justice, prob why they used them in the wal-mart demos. They are thin and can fit into small places, like a small room, or hang on a wall. However, I am just a college kid, and my budget is limited. Over the summer I got a Proview 32" LCD on a Costco special for $900.
http://www.proview.com/Product/Product_Page.aspx?sn=05090023&pi=121
I've been pleased with the HD cable quality and the regular TV picture overall. I'm not saying this is a top of the line lcd, but you definitely get your money's worth...and I purchased it for the most part for 360.
I also recently saw a Hyundai 32" sale for 800. Could be worth your while.
Brian @ Nov 21st 2005 6:51PM
Well if you want a great LCD TV in the Live-at-Home category Viewsonic makes a great HDTV without all of the bells and wistles but want great picture quality than you should really considor getting the N2750w. You can get it at Newegg for $760 with shipping. Heres a HERE.
jason w @ Nov 21st 2005 8:31PM
I have a Samsung that only does 1080i and 680p. I hope the upscale to 1080 i doesnt looks that bad. I hope to fond out in a few hours.
ben @ Nov 24th 2005 1:21PM
is it possible to connect through a DVI at all even through a dvi to YPrPb cable please help me i might be about to buy the wrong tv (philips 26PF4310)
EKorzon @ Nov 25th 2005 8:28PM
Somebody asked about the Qualia 006 from Sony. I haven't had a 360 to try on it, but the old xbox with component cables looked phenominal on it. It's VERY large, though, and that's a put-off for some people. 70" gaming is tough to get used to. Otherwise it's the best TV at that size on the market, period. It should be for the price.
The 50/60 Sony SXRD's seem to have better detail in the shadow areas (halo 2 is my test material) than the DLP's out there, IMO. I sell both at my store, so I've tested the Mits DLP and the Sony SXRD... that's my opinion.
David Weaver @ Nov 25th 2005 10:03PM
by the way the first paragraph of this article is true but misleading...even though there is no hdmi support you can buy an adapter for DVI so you can hook up your lcd monitor...heres a link to one.
http://www.monoprice.com/products/product.asp?c_id=104&cp_id=10419&cs_id=1041901&p_id=2398&seq=1&format=2&style=
TMonte @ Nov 25th 2005 11:54PM
I'm running a 360 with a 34" widescreen Sony tube ("Hi-Scan") using the component cables. It looks nothing short of amazing, and I can verify it looks best (smoothest) in 720p (including text).
Not to stray too far OT, but I'm also using an Onkyo 6.1 receiver over optical. Dolby Digital sounds incredible - if I sit exactly in the middle of the room while playing Madden '06, it's like I'm in the stadium... :)
This is a great article, and as long as you get the right features at the right price point, you will be very happy. My brother and my brother-in-law both have the 42" Samsung DLP (HLR4266W), and I can't wait to see it on one of those!
Good luck and happy gaming. :)
TM
James @ Nov 26th 2005 1:28AM
Pelican Accessories have the Xbox 360 HDMI cable in the works.
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/B000BCEJW2/qid=1132986420/sr=8-2/ref=sr_8_xs_ap_i1_xgl63/102-2835405-1682553?v=glance&s=videogames&n=507846
Isaac @ Nov 27th 2005 12:47AM
Has everyone forgotten the VGA connector?
I have a spare computer montior and im ready to play HDTV games via that CRT. Im told that some displays wont take the 720P resolution but hell, if i get 480p i'll be happier then the component (Yellow/red/white) for the x-box 360. I'm very dissapointed this system did not ship with a DVI port. Missing HDMI was dumb as well. I hope they correct those IMHO stupid issues.